Summer 2025
California Schools Logo
Lessons on Wildfires

Summer 2025

California Schools Logo
Volume 83, Number 4
Summer 2025

The California School Boards Association is the essential voice for public education. We inspire our members to be knowledgeable leaders, extraordinary governance practitioners and ardent advocates for all students.

Table of Contents
Table of Contents
features
cropped image of a playground engulfed in fire

LEA leaders share experiences and advice for navigating disaster

by Heather Kemp

cropped view of the mathematical imagery in orange and different shades of green

Can California’s new math framework help improve student outcomes?

by Kimberly Sellery

an artistic depiction of multiple diverse faces in silhouette against a textured, multi-colored background

Student diversity in California presents challenges and important opportunities for growth

by Alisha Kirby

departments
CEO’s note
by Vernon M. Billy
5
Legal insights
by Kristin Lindgren-Bruzzone
7
From the field
by Vanessa Sifuentes
9
Research spotlight
by Angela Asch
11
Member profile
Dave Zygielbaum, Torrance USD
13
BoardWise
by Parvin Ahmadi and Monika Moulin
17
CSBA at issue
by Christina Hecht
19
A conversation with…
Tani Cantil-Sakauye, president and CEO of the Public Policy Institute of California
49
Vernon M. Billy headshot

CEO’s note

by Vernon M. Billy

It’s time: The state must develop a coherent plan to close the achievement gap

L

ess than a year from now, on June 2, 2026, California will hold two elections with major implications for the future of public schools. Voters will head to the ballot box to cast votes in the State Primary and General Election for a new governor and state superintendent of public instruction (SSPI), respectively.

This regime change comes at a precipitous time for California schools. Statewide, schools are coping with stagnant test scores, persistent achievement gaps, declining enrollment, manipulation of Proposition 98 and myriad other issues. Nationally, the Trump administration has committed to downsizing the federal role in public schools. As the federal government pulls back direct support for education, the already important roles of governor and SSPI will loom even larger for those involved with California schools. The competition for these influential roles is intense, and no matter who prevails, there are foundational issues they must take to strengthen schools, support good governance and improve student outcomes. The next governor and SSPI will need to consider these foundational issues — starting with a full court press to address the state’s achievement gap.

CSBA 2025 Board of Directors

  • Tyler Nelson
    Region 1, Ukiah USD
  • Bruce Ross
    Region 2, Redding ESD
  • Robin Jankiewicz
    Region 3
  • Renee Nash
    Region 4, Eureka Union SD
  • Patricia Murray
    Region 5
  • Jackie Wong
    Region 6, Washington USD
  • Rachel Hurd
    Region 7, San Ramon Valley USD
  • Christopher “Kit” Oase
    Region 8, Ripon USD
  • Roger Snyder
    Region 9, Scotts Valley USD
  • Kathy Spate
    Region 10, Caruthers USD
  • Daniel Sandoval
    Region 11
  • William Farris
    Region 12, Sierra Sands USD
  • Annette Lewis
    Region 14, Contra Costa COE
  • Susan Henry
    Region 15, Huntington Beach Union HSD
  • Karen Gray
    Region 16, Silver Valley USD
  • Eleanor Evans
    Region 17, Oceanside USD
  • Bruce Dennis
    Region 18, Riverside COE
  • Devon Conley
    Region 20, Mountain View Whisman SD
  • Rocio Rivas
    Region 21
  • Nancy Smith
    Region 22, Palmdale SD
  • Helen Hall
    Region 23, Walnut Valley USD
  • Jan Baird
    Region 24, South Whittier ESD
  • Chris Clark
    Director-at-Large African American, Folsom-Cordova USD
  • Christina Cameron-Otero
    Director-at-Large American Indian, Needles USD
  • Sylvia Leong
    Director-at-Large Asian/Pacific Islander, Cupertino Union SD
  • Michael Teasdale
    Director-at-Large County, Ventura COE
  • Alma Carina Castro
    Director-at-Large Hispanic, Lynwood USD
Portrait headshot close-up photograph view of Kristin Lindgren-Bruzzone smiling

legal insights

By Kristin Lindgren-Bruzzone

Disparate impact discrimination theory under threat

T

he United States is experiencing a time of great change and agitation in the legal landscape. Among those areas of the law targeted for change is the legal theory of disparate impact discrimination.

This theory has long protected groups that are affected by discrimination based on inherent biases or the unintended consequences of otherwise neutral policies that nevertheless have a statistically negative impact. However, disparate treatment is under significant scrutiny today and that scrutiny may carry over to programs intended to address disparate impacts.

On April 23, 2025, President Donald Trump issued Executive Order 14281: Restoring Equality of Opportunity and Meritocracy, which is intended to begin the process to do away with the legal theory of disparate impact discrimination. Other administration actions such as the Department of Education’s (ED) Dear Colleague Letter on diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) issued in February 2025 seeks to restrict the use of disparate impact specifically in schools. This would present a sea change in both employment and education contexts, as this theory originated more than 50 years ago and has been repeatedly affirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court. While the Executive Order and Dear Colleague Letter do not completely eliminate disparate impact theory, this is a good time to recall the purposes and legal underpinnings of this theory and the Supreme Court jurisprudence that has upheld it.

California Schools logo

Chief Information Officer
Troy Flint, tflint@csba.org

Editorial Director
Kimberly Sellery, ksellery@csba.org

Senior Staff Writers
Heather Kemp, hkemp@csba.org
Alisha Kirby, akirby@csba.org

Director of Marketing and Communications
Monica Griffis, mgriffis@csba.org

Director of Graphic Design and Branding
Kerry Macklin, kmacklin@csba.org

Senior Graphic Designer
Amanda Moen, amoen@csba.org

Graphic Designer
Thairah Singharath, tsingharath@csba.org

Circulation and Advertising
csba@csba.org

CSBA officers

President
Dr. Bettye Lusk, Monterey Peninsula USD

President-elect
Dr. Debra Schade, Solana Beach SD

Vice President
Sabrena Rodriguez, Ventura USD

Immediate Past President
Albert Gonzalez, Santa Clara USD

CEO & Executive Director
Vernon M. Billy

California Schools (ISSN 1081-8936) is published quarterly by the California School Boards Association, Inc., 3251 Beacon Boulevard, West Sacramento, CA 95691, (916) 371-4691. $2 of CSBA membership dues goes toward the subscription to California Schools magazine for each board member and superintendent. The subscription rate for each CSBA nonmember is $20. Periodicals postage paid at West Sacramento, CA and at additional mailing office. Postmaster: Send address changes to California Schools, 3251 Beacon Blvd., West Sacramento, CA 95691.

Articles submitted to California Schools are edited for style, content and space prior to publication. Views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent CSBA policies or positions. Articles may not be reproduced without written permission of the publisher. Endorsement by CSBA of products and services advertised in California Schools is not implied or expressed.

CSBA and NSPRA logos
Vanessa Sifuentes headshot
from the field
by Vanessa Sifuentes

Oakland Unified School District: Transforming student futures through bond measures

A decade of community-driven investment

A close-up, eye-level shot of a smiling woman with long hair. She is wearing a dark graduation gown and cap.
In 2014, Oakland voters approved Measure N, followed by Measure H in 2022, catalyzing a districtwide transformation in high school education. Today, these targeted investments are yielding strong results — rising graduation rates, reducing dropout rates and increasing college and career readiness. These improvements are not coincidental; they are the direct result of a strategic, equity-focused use of Measure N and H funds, which have allowed for the expansion of Linked Learning Pathways and fundamentally reshaped the student experience in the Oakland Unified School District (OUSD).
A vision made possible by Measures N and H

The passage of the two measures enabled OUSD to design and expand Linked Learning Pathways across the district that are rooted in equity, relevance and real-world learning. These measures have delivered $850 per student per year, totaling millions in annual funding to support initiatives such as:

  • College and career readiness staffing
  • Academic counseling and credit recovery
Angela Asch headshot

research spotlight

By Angela Asch

May Delegate Assembly digs into CSBA Policy Pillars

C

SBA’s Delegate Assembly (DA) meets twice a year to receive updates from association leadership and to discuss issues facing local educational agencies (LEAs). The Delegates work with LEAs and CSBA’s Board of Directors and Executive Committee to ensure the interests of school districts and county offices of education throughout the state are top of mind. Delegates meet every May and before the CSBA Annual Education Conference and Trade Show in December.

Three children writing at desks in a classroom with educational posters in the background.
The Policy Platform, adopted by the DA every two years, serves as a foundation for any and all action CSBA takes on behalf of LEAs across the state.
Policy Pillars

Within the Policy Platform, four overarching pillars guide CSBA’s work on its vision for California’s children: to graduate prepared for post-high school success in college and the workforce with the skills to be lifelong learners and effective, contributing members of a global society. The pillars are: Strengthen Local Governance, Secure Fair Funding, Improve Conditions of Children and Ensure Achievement for All.

member profile - Dave Zygielbaum Trustee, Torrance Unified School District
How long have you been a board member and what inspired you to run for the position?

I was elected to the board in November 2024, and I chose to run because I believe in the power of public education to shape lives and strengthen communities. As the son of a lifelong teacher, I grew up understanding the impact of dedicated educators. To me, this role is about service, responsibility and commitment — some of my core values. I hope to bring a steady, thoughtful presence to the board by listening carefully, showing up consistently, and putting students, families and educators at the center of every decision.

How does your job as a prosecutor of crimes against children affect your perspective as a board member and what you focus on?

My work often shows me the hard reality that some kids face outside of school. It is a constant reminder that for many students, school is not just place to learn, but where they feel safest, supported and seen. That experience stays with me every time I sit at the board table. It reminds me that our responsibility goes beyond test scores or facilities. We need to make sure every student feels safe, cared for and connected.

You were a student board member at Bonita USD. How did that experience prepare you for service as an adult?

Serving as a student board member gave me an early, firsthand look at how school districts really operated, from budgeting and policy decisions to how those choices ultimately affect students in the classroom. I learned how to listen, ask questions and speak up with purpose, even when I was the youngest person in the room. That experience not only gave me confidence but taught me that leadership is not always about having the answers right away. That experience laid the foundation for how I approach board service today: with respect for the process, a focus on people and a deep belief in the value of public education.

Who inspired you growing up?

I have always been inspired by people with a strong sense of adventure and purpose. However, while I strongly admired astronauts and archaeologists, my family members were certainly my greatest inspiration. My maternal grandfather was a World War II Marine, who taught me resilience, dedication and compassion. My paternal grandparents were Holocaust survivors, who taught me perseverance, self-reliance and the importance of community. I was also inspired by the story of my great-grandfather, Szmul Zygielbojm, who sacrificed his life for the greater purpose of protecting others.

What is one major concern you hope to address as a board member?

Our schools must equip students with the tools, skills and confidence to thrive in a rapidly changing world. That is why I strongly support expanding early-college programs, so students can earn college credit while still in high school. These programs save families money, give students a head start, and expose them to the rigor and responsibility of higher education before graduation. At the same time, we must also invest in high-quality career technical education pathways. Not every student’s future looks the same, and our schools should reflect that. Our children are entering a world of fast-moving technology, evolving industries and global challenges. As a parent and public servant, I am committed to building an education system that is forward-looking, inclusive and full of opportunity.

Would you like to participate in an upcoming Member Profile? Contact editor@csba.org.

member profile - Dave Zygielbaum Trustee, Torrance Unified School District
How long have you been a board member and what inspired you to run for the position?

I was elected to the board in November 2024, and I chose to run because I believe in the power of public education to shape lives and strengthen communities. As the son of a lifelong teacher, I grew up understanding the impact of dedicated educators. To me, this role is about service, responsibility and commitment — some of my core values. I hope to bring a steady, thoughtful presence to the board by listening carefully, showing up consistently, and putting students, families and educators at the center of every decision.

How does your job as a prosecutor of crimes against children affect your perspective as a board member and what you focus on?

My work often shows me the hard reality that some kids face outside of school. It is a constant reminder that for many students, school is not just place to learn, but where they feel safest, supported and seen. That experience stays with me every time I sit at the board table. It reminds me that our responsibility goes beyond test scores or facilities. We need to make sure every student feels safe, cared for and connected.

You were a student board member at Bonita USD. How did that experience prepare you for service as an adult?

Serving as a student board member gave me an early, firsthand look at how school districts really operated, from budgeting and policy decisions to how those choices ultimately affect students in the classroom. I learned how to listen, ask questions and speak up with purpose, even when I was the youngest person in the room. That experience not only gave me confidence but taught me that leadership is not always about having the answers right away. That experience laid the foundation for how I approach board service today: with respect for the process, a focus on people and a deep belief in the value of public education.

Who inspired you growing up?

I have always been inspired by people with a strong sense of adventure and purpose. However, while I strongly admired astronauts and archaeologists, my family members were certainly my greatest inspiration. My maternal grandfather was a World War II Marine, who taught me resilience, dedication and compassion. My paternal grandparents were Holocaust survivors, who taught me perseverance, self-reliance and the importance of community. I was also inspired by the story of my great-grandfather, Szmul Zygielbojm, who sacrificed his life for the greater purpose of protecting others.

What is one major concern you hope to address as a board member?

Our schools must equip students with the tools, skills and confidence to thrive in a rapidly changing world. That is why I strongly support expanding early-college programs, so students can earn college credit while still in high school. These programs save families money, give students a head start, and expose them to the rigor and responsibility of higher education before graduation. At the same time, we must also invest in high-quality career technical education pathways. Not every student’s future looks the same, and our schools should reflect that. Our children are entering a world of fast-moving technology, evolving industries and global challenges. As a parent and public servant, I am committed to building an education system that is forward-looking, inclusive and full of opportunity.

Would you like to participate in an upcoming Member Profile? Contact editor@csba.org.

class act Best practices in action

class act
Best practices in action

Hemet USD students find confidence as literacy rates climb
District program supports students by supporting teachers

As much of the nation struggles to improve literacy rates among its youngest students, Hemet Unified School District — where nearly 87 percent of students are unduplicated homeless/foster youth, English learners or are low-income — has seen K-12 literacy rates skyrocket since implementing a new literacy program in 2021 focused on promoting best practices and building teacher capacity.

In partnership with WestEd, the district implemented a new strategy focused on continuous improvement, creating a system map to identify the moving parts within the literacy system, and using that information to design and implement systems that promote best practices, build capacity of teachers and leaders, and effectively measure and monitor student progress.

Three years ago, less than 15 percent of Hemet USD students in grades 2-12 were reading at grade level. That number has risen to 40 percent. Hemet USD Director of Literacy and Instructional Development Kristen Anderson said about 65 percent of first graders currently moving into second grade are anticipated to be reading at grade level.

Parvin Ahmad headshot
Monika Moulin headshot

BoardWise

By Parvin Ahmadi and Monika Moulin
Boardwise is a forum for board members and superintendents across the state to share questions about governance and board–superintendent relations. Send your questions to boardwise@csba.org. Have governance team questions that require personal attention? Reach out to gcs@csba.org for a customized Governance Consulting Workshop.
What should boards learn from staff progress reports on student achievement?
I

t is likely that new and veteran governance team members from local educational agencies both small and large throughout California find there are certain issues that can seem perennially insurmountable, despite boards devoting resources and energy to facing them. One such issue is how to close the achievement gap.

Overlapping pages containing line graphs, bar graphs, and pie charts.
Frustration in dealing with this particular concern abounds, and board members indicate that this is especially so when it seems that lawmakers in Sacramento impose requirements that make it harder for trustees and their superintendents to address the achievement gap. Balancing this frustration becomes easier when governance teams embrace and engage with data, particularly when they strive to understand how student achievement data, when monitored and ingested over time, can demonstrably benefit both operational decision-making and advocacy efforts.

As a veteran superintendent and former leader of the Association of California School Administrators (ACSA), I know the critical importance of measuring outcomes cannot be underestimated. After all, as educators and governing boards, we must hold ourselves accountable to the goals we set for our students, our system as a whole and ourselves. Using data to measure outcomes is an essential part of any improvement cycle, and everyone responsible for educating children needs data to make decisions.

Christina Hecht headshot

csba at issue

By Christina Hecht
California’s School Meals for All Program: Evaluation reveals a host of benefits
F

rom March 2020 through the 2021–22 school year, Congress and the U.S. Department of Agriculture enabled schools to provide free meals daily to all students to help relieve hunger during the COVID-19 pandemic.

female child with brown hair in braids eating carrot
With the 2022–23 school year, California was the first in the nation to adopt and fund a program to offer meals free of charge to every student in the state. Under School Meals for All (SMFA), sometimes referred to as universal school meals, all California public school students in grades TK-12 are offered breakfast and lunch every school day.

The state commissioned the Nutrition Policy Institute (NPI), in the University of California’s Agriculture and Natural Resources, to evaluate the program, see how implementation has worked, how it can be improved, and what impact it is making for students, families and schools.

Perhaps the most important thing to point out from the evaluation is how popular the program is among students and families. The majority of families want the program to continue because it not only provides healthy meals to students, but also saves families time and stress and helps to stretch their food budgets.

Lessons on wildfires
LEA leaders share experiences and advice for navigating disaster
by Heather Kemp

The Eaton Fire sparked on the evening of Jan. 7. Later that night, Pasadena Unified School District officials knew it was going to forever change the lives of its community.

Public Information Officer Hilda Ramirez Horvath said that the district had already activated its emergency operations center in anticipation of severe winds. Leaving work around 9 p.m., smoke was in the air with scattered ash and downed trees setting an unsettling scene. The district had announced earlier that schools would be closed the following day due to the fire.

Solving for success
Can California’s new math framework help improve student outcomes?
by Kimberly Sellery
Students in California and across the nation are struggling with math achievement. Alarmingly, more than 63 percent of all students did not meet the math standard on the 2023–24 California Assessment of Student Progress and Performance (CAASPP).
And while African American and Hispanic/Latino students saw gains compared to all students in the state, the achievement gap between these students and white and Asian students only slightly decreased. The California Department of Education (CDE) has described these groups’ progress as “accelerated,” but only in comparison to the modest gains by all students statewide. California has perennially had issues providing historically disadvantaged students with the resources necessary to help them meet curricular standards.
Solving for success
Can California’s new math framework help improve student outcomes?
by Kimberly Sellery
Students in California and across the nation are struggling with math achievement. Alarmingly, more than 63 percent of all students did not meet the math standard on the 2023–24 California Assessment of Student Progress and Performance (CAASPP).
And while African American and Hispanic/Latino students saw gains compared to all students in the state, the achievement gap between these students and white and Asian students only slightly decreased. The California Department of Education (CDE) has described these groups’ progress as “accelerated,” but only in comparison to the modest gains by all students statewide. California has perennially had issues providing historically disadvantaged students with the resources necessary to help them meet curricular standards.
The Melting Pot
Student diversity in California presents challenges and important opportunities for growth

The U.S. Census Bureau predicts that by 2044, the U.S. will no longer have a single ethnic majority. Recent analysis shows California ranks first for cultural diversity, having the highest linguistic diversity and the second-highest racial and ethnic diversity in the country. The Golden State also ranks third for socioeconomic diversity, fifth for household diversity and eighth for political diversity, according to Wallethub, which analyzed each state’s diversity level by evaluating and ranking six categories.

While the word “diversity” has become something of a flashpoint term, research shows that students in highly diverse schools tend to exhibit higher self-esteem, have reduced feelings of loneliness, report feeling safer in school and experience less peer-to-peer harassment — social-emotional and school climate factors that are all associated with increased academic achievement.

By Alisha Kirby
An artistic depiction of multiple diverse faces in silhouette against a textured, multi-colored background.
The Melting Pot

Student diversity in California presents challenges and important opportunities for growth

The U.S. Census Bureau predicts that by 2044, the U.S. will no longer have a single ethnic majority. Recent analysis shows California ranks first for cultural diversity, having the highest linguistic diversity and the second-highest racial and ethnic diversity in the country. The Golden State also ranks third for socioeconomic diversity, fifth for household diversity and eighth for political diversity, according to Wallethub, which analyzed each state’s diversity level by evaluating and ranking six categories.

While the word “diversity” has become something of a flashpoint term, research shows that students in highly diverse schools tend to exhibit higher self-esteem, have reduced feelings of loneliness, report feeling safer in school and experience less peer-to-peer harassment — social-emotional and school climate factors that are all associated with increased academic achievement.

By Alisha Kirby

a conversation with…

Tani Cantil-Sakauye, president and CEO, Public Policy Institute of California
Tani Cantil-Sakauye headshot
Tani Cantil-Sakauye is president and CEO of the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC), where she holds the Walter and Esther Hewlett Chair in Understanding California’s Future. From 2011 to 2022, she served as the 28th Chief Justice of California and led the judiciary as the chair of the Judicial Council — the constitutional policy and rulemaking body of the judicial branch. Prior to being elected Chief Justice, she served more than 20 years on California appellate and trial courts and was appointed or elevated to higher office by three governors.

a conversation with…

Tani Cantil-Sakauye, president and CEO, Public Policy Institute of California
Tani Cantil-Sakauye is president and CEO of the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC), where she holds the Walter and Esther Hewlett Chair in Understanding California’s Future. From 2011 to 2022, she served as the 28th Chief Justice of California and led the judiciary as the chair of the Judicial Council — the constitutional policy and rulemaking body of the judicial branch. Prior to being elected Chief Justice, she served more than 20 years on California appellate and trial courts and was appointed or elevated to higher office by three governors.
Tani Cantil-Sakauye headshot
What do some of the key findings in the recent PPIC statewide survey, “Californians and Education,” suggest about the status of public education at the state level?
Our latest “Californians and Education” survey, from April, suggests that there is concern about the quality of education in our state. Fifty-one percent of respondents say that California’s education system is heading in the wrong direction, while 84 percent say that the quality of education in our state is a big problem or somewhat of a problem. They are particularly concerned about how the system is addressing lower-income students: 82 percent are very concerned or somewhat concerned that public schools in lower-income areas have a shortage of good teachers compared to schools in wealthier areas, and 81 percent are very concerned or somewhat concerned that students in lower-income areas are less ready for college when they finish high school. Californians are also concerned about teacher shortages and teacher quality.
California Schools Logo

Thanks for reading our Summer 2025 issue!