CSBA and the broader local government coalition proposed a number of changes to existing law, taking into account the importance of ensuring survivors of these atrocious criminal actions receive justice and meaningful restitution while also preserving the ability of local educational agencies to retain fiscal solvency to continue serving current students. Chief among the proposals is the need to institute meaningful tort reform — caps on jury awards and settlement amounts — for future claims that balance the need for justice for victims while ensuring that LEAs can provide for the public good.
In response, Sen. John Laird (D-Santa Cruz) authored Senate Bill 577 to develop a mutually agreeable solution on this sensitive and controversial issue. Introduced in 2025, deliberations continued throughout the two-year 2025–26 legislative session.
Unfortunately, the bill was significantly amended with just three days remaining in the session — leaving no time for additional negotiations on needed tort reforms. Among its many changes, the amendments included improvements to existing law to help preserve victims’ rights, increased evidentiary standards for very old cases, a requirement that local agencies adopt codes of conduct and sexual assault prevention plans and that attorneys are held liable for bad faith claims. While all of this is a step in the right direction, fundamentally the language does not include reasonable caps on jury awards and settlement amounts, as requested by CSBA and other stakeholders.
Gov. Gavin Newsom acknowledged this in his signing message, where he stated that SB 577 “represents an important and necessary first step toward reform that simultaneously addresses the wrongs of the past while providing public institutions relief from certain plaintiffs and attorneys who may engage in unscrupulous conduct to exploit existing law and deprive actual victims of compensation, but I implore the Legislature to continue to make changes to further address this untenable situation.”
The Governor’s signing message is helpful in acknowledging that additional work is needed on this issue. However, it leaves unresolved the fundamental challenges facing districts and county offices of education — exploding settlement costs threatening their fiscal solvency. With no significant advancements in needed reforms, it is expected that this issue will extend into the next legislative session.
AB 715 also put in place a new complaints process whereby the state superintendent of public instruction, in coordination with the OCR, could take adverse action against a school district or teacher found to have not provided “factually accurate” instruction. Raising concerns about the impacts this could have on classroom instruction, CSBA shared in a letter to the Assembly Education Committee that it could cause teachers to “hesitate to engage students in thoughtful, academically sound discussions of complex historical or political topics out of fear that their context could be misinterpreted as noncompliant. The threat of complaints and investigations may lead educators to avoid controversial subjects altogether, which would ultimately narrow the curriculum and undermine student learning.”
Approaching this issue with the seriousness and sensitivity it deserves to help address and prevent instances of discrimination in public education while also ensuring any changes do not undermine student learning, CSBA worked with the authors and stakeholders to develop a mutually agreeable approach.
After several months of meetings and negotiations, an agreement was not reached and AB 2615 was shelved by the authors, leaving in place AB 715 as adopted.