The newly released GDTF III examines the state’s current challenges in three system-level areas: the balance between state guidance and local control, accountability and alignment, and the state’s capacity to train and support educators. It also identifies priorities for policymakers and practitioners. Those priorities have several implications for school district and county board of education members.
Among other considerations, this research supports CSBA’s ongoing work to strengthen state education governance by building a more coherent TK-12 system and establishing shared accountability between the state and LEAs, with the ultimate goal of improving student outcomes and eliminating achievement gaps. The findings make it clear that this will take reliable state support, including stable funding, investment in staff capacity and initiatives that fit together rather than piling up and straining district capacity.
California now enrolls about 5.7 million TK-12 students. Nearly a third are current or former English learners, and about two-thirds are socioeconomically disadvantaged. The evidence shows some progress: student achievement has improved over the past two decades, and chronic absenteeism has fallen from its pandemic peak, though it exceeds pre-pandemic levels. Other trends are more worrying. Enrollment is falling in most districts, achievement gaps are pervasive and persistent, and administrators spend a growing share of their time on compliance paperwork.
Balance between state guidance and local control. LEAs carry substantial responsibilities and make consequential decisions, yet the state offers limited guidance on how to address persistent instructional challenges. LCFF’s equity-focused design has shown real promise, but unstable revenues make it hard for LEAs to plan and ensure program sustainability.
Accountability and alignment. California has many accountability tools and data systems that are poorly connected to one another. State initiatives, governance structures and policies have multiplied, each with their own reporting requirements. LEAs struggle to connect them, make sense of them and turn them into sustained action. One report on compliance burdens reinforces CSBA’s ongoing advocacy from its 2024 Drowning in Documentation work and subsequent legislation.
State capacity. The workforce and support system the future depends on are not yet strong or consistent enough. Teacher shortages, uneven preparation, fragmented support and leadership instability all limit what LEAs and schools can do.
Turning compliance into improvement. Current accountability reporting does not clearly separate compliance that supports core functions from compliance that adds burden with little value. LEAs are often clear about goals and plans but weaker on measurement, support and implementation. Boards can push to make the Local Control and Accountability Plan a genuine improvement plan, with numeric targets for named student groups. If the state streamlines its reporting, as the evidence suggests it should, boards should ask whether new tools fit their context and whether they replace old requirements rather than pile on top of them. CSBA will continue to advocate on these issues on behalf of LEAs.
Planning for fiscal uncertainty. Falling enrollment and unstable revenues affect most LEAs. As the state works towards more alignment across initiatives and funds, this points to a need for LEAs to plan for and report their local costs. Boards can ask their superintendents for multi-year enrollment and revenue projections, and for a clear account of how current commitments would hold up if either decline. Given the fiscal pressure many declining enrollment districts face, the topic of school closures may be raised locally. Notably, a statewide analysis of every district from 2011 to 2019 in one of the GDTF III studies found no statistically significant improvement in district finances, in part because declining enrollment due to families leaving after a closure can cancel out the savings from the closed building. The study raises considerations that governance teams should address during related conversations.
These findings speak to two of a board’s central responsibilities: fiscal stewardship and student outcomes. Sacramento can feel far from trustees’ LEAs, but its decisions shape what happens in every classroom. Neither stable finances nor narrower achievement gaps can be achieved by either level alone. They take state systems and local boards working together.
-Andres Fernandez-Vergara is a CSBA Fellow and UCLA doctoral student.