Governance corner
Practical tips from our MIG faculty
Enhancing school governance: The value of board self-evaluation in achieving student success

In the dynamic landscape of education, effective governance is pivotal to the success of a local educational agency and in shaping students’ educational journey. To strengthen the board’s commitment to excellence, they should engage in continuous improvement. One powerful tool recommended by Board Bylaw 9400 is the board self-evaluation, which states, “The Governing Board shall annually conduct a self-evaluation in order to demonstrate accountability to the community and ensure that district governance effectively supports student achievement and the attainment of the district’s vision and goals.”

Board self-evaluation is a reflective process where trustees assess their collective performance and identify strengths and areas for improvement. This introspective exercise is not just a procedural requirement but a catalyst for growth and progress within the LEA.

Benefits of board self-evaluation:
  • Enhanced communication and collaboration: Self-evaluation fosters open communication among board members, leading to a better understanding of individual strengths and weaknesses.
  • Improved leadership skills: Through self-assessment, board members can identify areas where leadership skills can be honed, allowing for targeted professional development.
  • Alignment with district goals: A well-conducted self-evaluation ensures that the board’s activities align with the overarching goals of the school district. This alignment is critical for creating a cohesive vision that supports student achievement.
  • Increased accountability: Self-evaluation holds board members accountable for their responsibilities. By recognizing areas that need improvement, members can set concrete goals and commit to ongoing development, ultimately strengthening the board’s impact on the district.
How board self-evaluation informs goal setting:
  • Data-driven decision making: The self-evaluation process involves analyzing data on board performance, which ensures that goals are set based on objectively assessing the board’s strengths and weaknesses.
  • Identifying strategic priorities: Self-evaluation helps boards identify strategic priorities and goals for the LEA. By aligning goals with the LEA’s needs, the board can focus on initiatives that directly contribute to student success. It is also a key tool that can be used to support the superintendent in leading the school system toward achieving those goals, as it plays a role in framing the superintendent’s goals and annual evaluation.
  • Creating a student-centric vision: Through self-evaluation, board members gain insights into how their decisions impact student outcomes, ensuring that all board actions are geared towards optimizing the learning experience.

Board self-evaluation is a powerful tool for enhancing the effectiveness of California boards of education. As members engage in this reflective process, they pave the way for improved communication, enhanced leadership skills and, most importantly, the alignment of their goals with the overarching mission of the LEA. By setting informed goals, boards contribute significantly to the pursuit of academic excellence and student achievement. Embracing the self-evaluation process is an investment in the continuous improvement of school governance, ensuring a brighter future for the students they serve.

CSBA’s Board Self-Evaluation Tool has helped numerous governance teams pause to reflect on their effectiveness, enhancing board governance capacity. CSBA offers the board self-evaluation as a stand-alone tool or through a facilitated workshop or study session with a governance consultant.

Visit to learn more.