Winter 2026
California Schools logo
Closing student achievement gaps

Winter 2026

California Schools Logo
Volume 84, Number 2
Winter 2026

The California School Boards Association is the essential voice for public education. We inspire our members to be knowledgeable leaders, extraordinary governance practitioners and ardent advocates for all students.

Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Vernon M. Billy headshot

CEO’s note

by Vernon M. Billy

California’s collective bargaining crossroads
Local negotiations can’t fix a state-level problem
C

alifornia’s current wave of collective bargaining is unfolding in one of the most complex and fragile fiscal environments in decades. Coordinated campaigns and strike headlines may suggest the central question is whether school districts are willing to prioritize educators, but that framing misses a deeper reality: the most powerful levers shaping districts are controlled not locally, but in Sacramento.

Two young girls with backpacks wave happily over their shoulders as they walk toward a school building.
If California truly wants fully staffed schools, competitive compensation, smaller classes and expanded student supports, then the conversation must expand beyond local bargaining to include the state’s funding architecture, its manipulation of Proposition 98, and the absence of a coherent statewide strategy to support school districts and county offices of education.

Despite what some may claim, school board members and superintendents don’t accept these positions because they harbor a secret desire to sabotage the labor movement or to impoverish teachers. They stepped into those roles because they cherish education, respect its value to society and want to develop the best possible version of public schools for their communities. Trustees and superintendents recognize how integral teachers are to that vision, and they want to reward teachers for their incredibly important work. Yet, these desires don’t occur in a vacuum.

CSBA 2026 Board of Directors

  • Tyler Nelson
    Region 1, Ukiah USD
  • Bruce Ross
    Region 2, Redding ESD
  • Robin Jankiewicz
    Region 3
  • Renee Nash
    Region 4, Eureka Union SD
  • Patricia Murray
    Region 5
  • Jackie Thu-Huong Wong
    Region 6, Washington USD
  • Rachel Hurd
    Region 7, San Ramon Valley USD
  • Christopher “Kit” Oase
    Region 8, Ripon USD
  • Roger Snyder
    Region 9, Scotts Valley USD
  • Kathy Spate
    Region 10, Caruthers USD
  • Daniel Sandoval
    Region 11
  • William Farris
    Region 12, Sierra Sands USD
  • Annette Lewis
    Region 14, Contra Costa COE
  • Susan Henry
    Region 15, Huntington Beach Union HSD
  • Karen Gray
    Region 16, Silver Valley USD
  • Eleanor Evans
    Region 17, Oceanside USD
  • Bruce Dennis
    Region 18, Riverside COE
  • Devon Conley
    Region 20, Mountain View Whisman SD
  • Rocio Rivas
    Region 21
  • Nancy Smith
    Region 22, Palmdale SD
  • Helen Hall
    Region 23, Walnut Valley USD
  • Jan Baird
    Region 24, South Whittier ESD
  • Chris Clark
    Director-at-Large African American, Folsom-Cordova USD
  • Christina Cameron-Otero
    Director-at-Large American Indian, Needles USD
  • Sylvia Leong
    Director-at-Large Asian/Pacific Islander, Cupertino Union SD
  • Michael Teasdale
    Director-at-Large County, Ventura COE
  • Alma Carina Castro
    Director-at-Large Hispanic, Lynwood USD
Dana Scott

legal insights

By Dana scott
Free speech in schools
The continuing development of student and employee rights
S

ince the U.S. Supreme Court’s holdings that the Constitutional guarantee of free speech extends to both students and employees in schools, questions about the scope of that right have persisted and, with recent events, have gained significant media attention. Social media, political debates and current events have tested the public’s understanding of the concept of free speech and, given the pivotal role of local educational agencies in communities, it is no surprise that schools have been at the center of many emerging legal questions.

A conceptual illustration featuring a grayscale open palm holding a large yellow speech bubble, with small birds flying away from the top edge.
As a result, it is beneficial for LEAs to stay up to date on relevant judicial decisions to know how courts are deciding these matters and what speech and limitations are permissible. Additionally, understanding legal precedent can aid LEAs as they navigate new issues. This article aims to explore the history of free speech for students and employees and describe recent decisions to highlight how this area of the law is evolving.
California Schools logo

Chief Information Officer
Troy Flint, tflint@csba.org

Editorial Director
Kimberly Sellery, ksellery@csba.org

Senior Staff Writers
Heather Kemp, hkemp@csba.org
Alisha Kirby, akirby@csba.org

Director of Marketing and Communications
Monica Griffis, mgriffis@csba.org

Director of Graphic Design and Branding
Kerry Macklin, kmacklin@csba.org

Senior Graphic Designer
Amanda Moen, amoen@csba.org

Graphic Designer
Thairah Singharath, tsingharath@csba.org

Circulation and Advertising
csba@csba.org

CSBA officers

President
Dr. Debra Schade, Solana Beach SD

President-elect
Sabrena Rodriguez, Ventura USD

Vice President
Jackie Thu-Huong Wong, Washington USD

Immediate Past President
Dr. Bettye Lusk, Monterey Peninsula USD

CEO & Executive Director
Vernon M. Billy

California Schools (ISSN 1081-8936) is published quarterly by the California School Boards Association, Inc., 3251 Beacon Boulevard, West Sacramento, CA 95691, (916) 371-4691. $2 of CSBA membership dues goes toward the subscription to California Schools magazine for each board member and superintendent. The subscription rate for each CSBA nonmember is $20. Periodicals postage paid at West Sacramento, CA and at additional mailing office. Postmaster: Send address changes to California Schools, 3251 Beacon Blvd., West Sacramento, CA 95691.

Articles submitted to California Schools are edited for style, content and space prior to publication. Views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent CSBA policies or positions. Articles may not be reproduced without written permission of the publisher. Endorsement by CSBA of products and services advertised in California Schools is not implied or expressed.

CSBA and NSPRA logos
A Century of Leadership

CSBA Presidents from 1931 to 2031

To mark the upcoming 100th anniversary of CSBA in 2031, California Schools is taking a historical look at the CSBA Presidents from 1931 to the future President in 2031.

Prompted by discussions among several boards throughout California about the need to advocate for educational programs, 29 school board members from 12 counties gathered at the Donner School auditorium in Sacramento on Sept. 8, 1931, to form the California School Trustees Association, later to be known as the California School Boards Association. The association began with a simple mission statement: “The purpose of the organization shall be to promote the best interests of the schools of the State of California”.

Congratulations

to CSBA’s Masters in Governance® Class of 2025!*

More than 2,000 board members and superintendents have participated in CSBA’s highly acclaimed Masters in Governance program.

CSBA’s Masters in Governance (MIG) program equips board members and superintendents with the knowledge and skills to build and support an effective governance structure.

The following graduates have successfully completed the 2025 in-person and virtual MIG program, gaining essential knowledge for being an effective governance team member.

Alvord USD
Amanda Vasquez

Apple Valley USD
Anita Tucker
Renee Longshore

Auburn Union ESD
Greg Holt
Emily Travis

Bass Lake Joint Union ESD
Denise Cudd

Buckeye Union ESD
Melissa Keyzer

Carmel USD
Matt Glazer

Central Union HSD
Beatriz Mora
Deby Ellet
Yolanda Tabarez

Ceres USD
Amy Peterman
Cynthia Ruiz

Julia Fallon
from the field
By Julia Fallon
The time has come for K-12’s “Great Modernization”
A

s artificial intelligence (AI)-powered education technology (edtech) apps proliferate and post-pandemic achievement gaps widen, school board leaders are feeling the pressure to modernize learning, perhaps now more than ever before. But what does modernization actually mean in K-12 education? Why is it so important? And how can boards of education lead modernization efforts in a way that helps, rather than harms, the students they serve?

A young girl looks at a tablet displaying a holographic robot assistant with speech bubbles like "HI..." and "CAN I HELP YOU?"
To be clear, when I talk about modernization, I’m not talking about adding more technology for technology’s sake. It’s not about using AI to automate tasks without improving the underlying process or replacing a whiteboard with a smartboard. If the influx of devices during the pandemic had truly modernized schools, then we wouldn’t have ended up with disconnected systems, overwhelmed educators, and parents and students juggling logins across multiple platforms. What we got instead was a fragmented, often chaotic experience. Modernization isn’t just digitization. It’s about fundamentally rethinking how our systems work, with intentional design, interoperability and human-centered outcomes at the core.
Close-up headshot of Jeremy Anderson, a man with a shaved head and a short dark brown beard, smiling warmly; He is wearing brown-rimmed prescription eyeglasses, a light-blue dress shirt, and a navy-blue suit jacket against a dark-grey background

research spotlight

By Jeremy Anderson
Transforming a single number to the Dashboard

25 years of California’s accountability system

Over the past 25 years, California has implemented significant reforms in how it holds local educational agencies accountable for student outcomes. The accountability system evolved from a narrow focus in the early 2000s to a more comprehensive approach with the introduction of the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) and the Local Control and Accountability Plan (LCAP) in 2013. California’s state accountability system is also closely tied to changes in federal education law, which have caused radical shifts in the methods state leaders use to hold LEAs accountable.

Over a decade after implementing the LCFF and LCAP, discussions continue on how to improve the state’s accountability system to better support student outcomes, especially addressing persistent achievement gaps. Although California’s accountability systems can be viewed from different angles, this article examines two distinct eras of the past 25 years before exploring where the state might head next.

member profile - Larissa Scors Anderson, Board President, Bonsall Unified School District
You’ve served as a trustee in Saddleback Valley USD for nearly 25 years — serving as Board President for seven of those. What is the accomplishment you are most proud of?

If I had to pick one accomplishment I’m most proud of, it would be helping launch and sustain our district’s Newcomer Camp, now in its fourth year. The camp supports students who are new to the United States or still learning English, giving them a chance to strengthen their language skills, build confidence and feel welcomed in our schools. Seeing students arrive shy and unsure, and leave with new friendships, stronger communication skills and ready to participate in our classrooms is incredibly rewarding.

Who inspired you growing up?

My parents inspired me from a very early age. They were always involved in our schools, working to ensure all kids, regardless of background, felt included and free to learn. They were also prolific letter writers supporting our public schools and taught me and my sisters how active participation in our community could make life better for everyone. Through their actions, we learned that if we want schools and a community where everyone can feel welcome and thrive, then we must actively participate and volunteer.

What advice do you have for new or aspiring board members?

Invest the time to take Masters in Governance and learn the responsibilities and work of being a trustee. Being a member of a governance team is truly different than anything else they have ever done — no matter how prepared they think they are.

How important are advocacy and establishing partnerships to your role as a trustee?

Advocacy and establishing partnerships are absolutely key to being an effective trustee. Being a publicly elected official, doors open more easily and create numerous opportunities to reach out and bring vital resources to the children we serve, like crossing guards, school resource officers, student internships, inspirational speakers, musical instruments, arts and science programs, career technical education tools, school supplies, mental health support, food and clothing pantries, and so much more.

What role did CSBA play in your journey as a trustee?

CSBA has played a huge role in my development as a trustee! Masters in Governance, seminars, the Annual Education Conference and Trade Show, Delegate Assembly, networking and advocacy all provided me opportunities to learn, grow and navigate more effectively in my role as a school board member, especially during difficult times. CSBA also provided a deeper understanding of the rich diversity of school districts in our state — from small and rural, to large and urban.

Would you like to participate in an upcoming Member Profile? Contact editor@csba.org.

member profile - Larissa Scors Anderson, Board President, Bonsall Unified School District
You’ve served as a trustee in Saddleback Valley USD for nearly 25 years — serving as Board President for seven of those. What is the accomplishment you are most proud of?

If I had to pick one accomplishment I’m most proud of, it would be helping launch and sustain our district’s Newcomer Camp, now in its fourth year. The camp supports students who are new to the United States or still learning English, giving them a chance to strengthen their language skills, build confidence and feel welcomed in our schools. Seeing students arrive shy and unsure, and leave with new friendships, stronger communication skills and ready to participate in our classrooms is incredibly rewarding.

Who inspired you growing up?

My parents inspired me from a very early age. They were always involved in our schools, working to ensure all kids, regardless of background, felt included and free to learn. They were also prolific letter writers supporting our public schools and taught me and my sisters how active participation in our community could make life better for everyone. Through their actions, we learned that if we want schools and a community where everyone can feel welcome and thrive, then we must actively participate and volunteer.

What advice do you have for new or aspiring board members?

Invest the time to take Masters in Governance and learn the responsibilities and work of being a trustee. Being a member of a governance team is truly different than anything else they have ever done — no matter how prepared they think they are.

How important are advocacy and establishing partnerships to your role as a trustee?

Advocacy and establishing partnerships are absolutely key to being an effective trustee. Being a publicly elected official, doors open more easily and create numerous opportunities to reach out and bring vital resources to the children we serve, like crossing guards, school resource officers, student internships, inspirational speakers, musical instruments, arts and science programs, career technical education tools, school supplies, mental health support, food and clothing pantries, and so much more.

What role did CSBA play in your journey as a trustee?

CSBA has played a huge role in my development as a trustee! Masters in Governance, seminars, the Annual Education Conference and Trade Show, Delegate Assembly, networking and advocacy all provided me opportunities to learn, grow and navigate more effectively in my role as a school board member, especially during difficult times. CSBA also provided a deeper understanding of the rich diversity of school districts in our state — from small and rural, to large and urban.

Would you like to participate in an upcoming Member Profile? Contact editor@csba.org.

class act Best practices in action

class act
Best practices in action

West Covina USD’s Speech and Debate Program prepares students for success

A young boy in a suit raises his fists in victory while wearing a champion belt, standing next to a smiling man in a gym.
Resilience, critical thinking and confidence are just a few of the skills that participants in West Covina Unified School District’s Golden Bell Award-winning Speech and Debate Program gain.

Superintendent Emy Flores is a strong advocate of the program, implementing similar efforts at previous local educational agencies she helped lead before joining the Los Angeles County district in early 2022. By the end of that year, West Covina USD launched its initiative as a summer camp, which drew immediate interest from the community, Flores recalled.

Close-up headshot of Daryl Camp, a smiling man with a shaved head; He is wearing a blue dress shirt, a navy-blue and red striped bowtie, and a black suit jacket against a textured blue-green background
Close-up headshot of Angelina Pride, a smiling woman with dark, chin-length hair styled in a bob with bangs; She is wearing gold hoop earrings, a white collared shirt, and a navy-blue blazer, posing against a background of green leafy foliage
Close-up headshot of Deborah Sims, a smiling woman with dark, curly hair wearing a lime-green blazer and a small silver necklace

BoardWise

By Daryl Camp, Angelina Pride and Deborah Sims

Boardwise is a forum for board members and superintendents across the state to share questions about governance and board–superintendent relations. Send your questions to boardwise@csba.org. Have governance team questions that require personal attention? Reach out to gcs@csba.org for a customized Governance Consulting Workshop.

Dear BoardWise: How can boards best lead through divisive times?
In an era marked by deep division and heightened public scrutiny, boards of education cannot rely on business-as-usual approaches to governance. Trust, collaboration and a strong board culture are not optional, they are the essential elements that enable governance teams to stay focused on students, remain unified in purpose and lead with integrity.
Building trust
In the past, school board meetings were held in quiet rooms, where decisions were discussed and debated with respect and consideration. We now see national tensions and disagreement playing out at board meetings across the state and country. For boards to govern effectively in this climate, they must prioritize building trust, fostering collaboration and cultivating a strong board culture.

Advertorial

Health-e-Kids helps schools unlock CYBHI funding with near-perfect claims success

Practi-Cal’s integrated platform helps LEAs streamline billing, ensure compliance, and unlock sustainable funding for student mental health.
California’s Children and Youth Behavioral Health Initiative (CYBHI) aim to enhance access to mental health services for students. The need for such services is urgent, as rising rates of anxiety, depression, and other behavioral health challenges are impacting children throughout the state. The biggest hurdle schools face is not recognizing this need; instead, it is securing the sustainable funding necessary to provide these services.

Health-e-Kids, developed by Practi-Cal, is transforming this scenario. Designed specifically for school health teams, Health-e-Kids helps Local Educational Agencies (LEAs) navigate the complexities of CYBHI billing, ensuring that schools receive the reimbursements they deserve.

Joe Feldman
csba at issue
By Joe Feldman
Why is there so much pushback against equitable grading?
Also known as standards-based grading, which doesn’t include non-academic criteria
woman looking at folder of graded papers

Throughout my years as a teacher, principal and district administrator, grading in schools was like the old joke about the weather: everyone complained, no one did anything. Students, families and faculty knew that no teachers graded the same. Two students in adjacent Algebra I rooms could have identical understanding yet receive different grades because of variation in late-work penalties, tardies, extra credit or participation points. The variability was understandable — most teachers receive little preparation for how to grade — but it was also confounding; district leaders’ attempts to increase consistency in grading often would devolve into accusations of administrative overreach and threats to teacher autonomy.

Closing
Student
Achievement
Gaps
CSBA’s call to action for a state-level operations and support plan to address a decades-long issue
Closing
Student
Achievement
Gaps
by Heather Kemp
Seasoned and new education leaders alike should be aware of and troubled by an issue that has plagued K-12 public education in California: achievement gaps among student groups.

Though local educational agencies are consistently held accountable for the role they play in the outcomes of learners through metrics included on the California School Dashboard, their students’ California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (CAASPP) scores and other means, no such formal measures exist at the state level.

Over the years, CSBA has been concerned by the lack of meaningful action on the topic and advocated for the disparities to be addressed. However, due to the state’s ongoing lack of urgency and accountability on the matter, worries have amplified and resulted in a call to action that CSBA CEO & Executive Director Vernon M. Billy explained to members during the 2025 Annual Education Conference and Trade Show (AEC), which took place Dec. 3-5 in Sacramento.

CSBA’s call to action for a state-level operations and support plan to address a decades-long issue
by Heather Kemp
Seasoned and new education leaders alike should be aware of and troubled by an issue that has plagued K-12 public education in California: achievement gaps among student groups.

Though local educational agencies are consistently held accountable for the role they play in the outcomes of learners through metrics included on the California School Dashboard, their students’ California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (CAASPP) scores and other means, no such formal measures exist at the state level.

Over the years, CSBA has been concerned by the lack of meaningful action on the topic and advocated for the disparities to be addressed. However, due to the state’s ongoing lack of urgency and accountability on the matter, worries have amplified and resulted in a call to action that CSBA CEO & Executive Director Vernon M. Billy explained to members during the 2025 Annual Education Conference and Trade Show (AEC), which took place Dec. 3-5 in Sacramento.

“For too long, local educational agencies have shouldered accountability for student outcomes under a fragmented and disjointed state system,” Billy said. “That’s why CSBA is calling for a new approach in California, one where the state transitions from piecemeal programs, pet projects, one-off dictates and underfunded mandates to one guided by a coherent state-focused operations and support plan that strengthens LEAs’ work to close achievement gaps.
a large hand holds a young boy wearing a backpack up to a large star in the sky
Providing a sense of purpose
College and career education paves a bright path forward for underserved youth
by Alisha Kirby
The Bathroom Bandits — a group of special education students attending high school in San Joaquin County — earned the nickname from administrators and teachers because they would ditch class and hide out in the bathroom together to pass the time. They missed a lot of classes and consistently got into trouble.
Until they found a purpose.
T

he Bathroom Bandits joined WorkAbility I (WAI), a career awareness, exploration and training program for special education students ages 12 to 22, and were hired to operate the snack bar during soccer games.

School staff “were hoping that was going to be that carrot that kept them engaged and wanting to be at school and continue to persevere,” said Zach Franceschetti, San Joaquin County Office of Education WAI program coordinator. Historically, the program has had significant impacts on students, he explained.

California takes on its literacy challenge
Will new legislation combined with existing initiatives move the needle on student literacy?
By Kimberly Sellery
California takes on its literacy challenge
Will new legislation combined with existing initiatives move the needle on student literacy?
By Kimberly Sellery
W

hile state leaders lauded incremental improvements in English language arts (ELA) demonstrated by 2025 California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress results, they also acknowledged there is more work to be done, with less than half of the state’s 5.8 million students meeting grade-level standards. Additionally, large gaps in achievement between student groups continue to languish without the movement needed to accelerate outcomes in lower-achieving groups.

During an Oct. 9 webinar attended by education leaders, policymakers and media, CSBA called for the State of California to adopt a coherent, state-level plan for how it will better support — not dictate — the work of local educational agencies in closing achievement gaps.

Standing up for public education
CSBA’s 2025 Legislative Scorecard
W

ith the 2025 legislative year in the rearview mirror, it is time to release CSBA’s annual Legislative Scorecard. The scorecard is a helpful tool to assess how your state legislators are voting on important measures that impact school districts, county boards of education and public education overall. Last year saw more than 800 bills reach Gov. Gavin Newsom’s desk, which included a number of high profile education bills. They included legislation to address the growing incidences of antisemitism, efforts to increase nonclassroom-based charter school oversight and helping alleviate the teacher shortage by allowing substitutes to serve longer in a classroom.

Notably, four CSBA-sponsored measures reached the Governor’s desk with just one vetoed and the rest signed into law. The three bills signed by Gov. Newsom will help to expand access to education workforce housing, modernize decades-old school district and county board of education stipends, and reduce administrative workloads. The fourth bill would have provided much-needed relief to school districts and county offices of education by temporarily expanding the time a substitute teacher may teach in a classroom from 30 to 60 days.

a conversation with…

CSBA President Dr. Debra Schade
CSBA President Dr. Debra Schade
2026 CSBA President Dr. Debra Schade is a trustee in the Solana Beach School District, where she has served for 23 years. She previously held the role of Vice President of the San Diego County School Boards Association, demonstrating her commitment to local and regional educational leadership. Her professional background is in research, technology and entrepreneurship, which fuels her advocacy for early computer science literacy. She serves on the board of The League of Amazing Programmers, a nonprofit that provides underserved youth with programming instruction, engineering skills and career-focused development.

a conversation with…

CSBA President Dr. Debra Schade
2026 CSBA President Dr. Debra Schade is a trustee in the Solana Beach School District, where she has served for 23 years. She previously held the role of Vice President of the San Diego County School Boards Association, demonstrating her commitment to local and regional educational leadership. Her professional background is in research, technology and entrepreneurship, which fuels her advocacy for early computer science literacy. She serves on the board of The League of Amazing Programmers, a nonprofit that provides underserved youth with programming instruction, engineering skills and career-focused development.
CSBA President Dr. Debra Schade
digital illustration of young child with various icons above his head like gears, rocket ship, science beaker, light bulb, and motorcycle
Can you tell us a bit about your background, including how long you’ve been a board member, your own K-12 education and your professional experience?
I was born in the Bay Area to a father who was a naval officer and pilot, and I grew up with a sense of discipline, curiosity and drive from an early age. Growing up, I moved frequently and attended public schools in the United States and abroad, each with its own approach to academics. I experienced firsthand how dramatically standards and expectations can vary from one system to another. For example, in one state, earning top marks required near-perfect scores and a deep level of preparation; the rigor pushed students to think critically and truly master the material. In another, the grading scale was far more forgiving; expectations were noticeably lower, and it was surprisingly easy to do well with minimal effort. Living through those contrasts made something very clear: low expectations come at a high cost. When students aren’t challenged, they miss opportunities to grow, to discover what they’re capable of, and to build the confidence that comes from meaningful achievement. That awareness has stayed with me and continues to fuel my belief in the importance of high-quality education and consistent standards for every student — no matter where they live.
California Schools Logo

Thanks for reading our Winter 2026 issue!